I want a verdict against both of them, he says. While those criticisms are more than valid, there is no question that the trial has provided an extraordinary spectacle and a cast of unforgettable supporting characters who have found themselves unlikely cult celebrities. The jury will return on Tuesday for deliberations. Johnny Depp asks to strike inappropriate argument in Amber Heard closing statement, Tuesday 31 May 2022 22:10 , Clemence Michallon, A trial by TikTok and the death knell for MeToo. WARNING: This article contains allegations of physical and sexual violence that some readers may find distressing. The jury returned its verdict on Wednesday after three days of deliberation at the district court. He will not like to bring it in New York, for we are known here, nor in Otsego, for he is known there, wrote editor Horace Greeley. In discussions with The Independent during the fourth week of proceedings, three attorneys highlighted the high standard Mr Depp must reach if he hopes to win his defamation case the same standard Ms Heard must also meet if she wants her countersuit against Mr Depp to be successful. Barkin was called by Heards team and testified that Depp was a jealous man who drank all the time and once hurled a wine bottle in her direction. Tuesday 31 May 2022 13:40 , Oliver O'Connell. According to Court TV, the jurors include five men and two women, with two alternate jurors remaining on standby if one of the main pool is dismissed or needs to drop out. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Depps legal claims stemmed from Heards 2018 Washington Post op-ed. Im even more disappointed with what this verdict means for other women. She continued, It sets back the clock to a time when a woman who spoke up and spoke out could be publicly shamed and humiliated. After the verdict was read and the jury left the room, his legal team gave each other hugs. The actor failed last year to get an appeal in that UK libel suit. Amber received $7 million from the settlement, all of which was reportedly donated to charity. The "Aquaman" actress won a $2 million jury verdict against Depp on one of her claims that he defamed her. Testimony painted a disturbing portrait of a doomed marriage, laying bare violent fights, drug use, and vicious words to each other. Abadi, the founder of the Female Composer Safety League, has not revealed publicly who hurt her. Each day of the trial, hoards of his fans packed the courtroom gallery, and the seats became so in demand people lined up at 1 a.m. to get a chance to see Depp in the flesh. In closing arguments on Friday, Depps lawyers asked jurors to give him his life back after it was ruined by Heards domestic abuse allegations. Upon passing the case over, Judge Penney Azcarate cautioned jurors against jumping to quick conclusions and instructed them to carefully review all relevant evidence before reaching a verdict. Although the article did not mention Johnny by name, the timing of the article following their divorce created the public impression that he was her abuser. AP. The jury of five men and two women did rule for Heard in one of her claims, that she was defamed when Depps attorney Adam Waldman said in an interview that she and her friends set the actor up with an ambush, a hoax on the night of an argument between the couple in May 2016. A Fairfax County Circuit Court jury found Wednesday that Amber Heard defamed ex-husband Johnny Depp with a 2018 opinion article in which she described herself as a representative of domestic. According to Ibrahim, Equal Rights Advocates has received calls from students as young as 15 who were afraid of being sued for defamation for reporting an assault to their school or going to a Take Back the Night rally. Was Mallory Beach Ever Found? Depp and Heard are suing each other for defamation. Johnny Depp 's defamation lawsuit against Amber Heard continues this week in Fairfax County, Va., shining a light on their tumultuous relationship while igniting discussions and debate about. Amber Heards lawyer raised eyebrows in his closing argument as he sought to downplay the importance of a fight in which Johnny Depps finger was severed. Amber Heard Says She Is Heartbroken By Verdict: The Disappointment I Feel Today Is Beyond Words. She is countersuing over his claim that her allegations are a hoax. Okay, TikTok, You Can Calm Down About Aubrey Plaza at the SAG Awards Now, All 165 Pink Floyd Songs Ranked, From Worst to Best. Amber will have to pay Johnny $10 million in compensatory damages and $5 million in punitive damages for a total of $15 million. Now its every two weeks, he says. All seven elements have to be present for the jury to rule in Mr Depps favor for each statement. The "Aquaman" actress won a $2 million jury verdict against Depp on one of her claims that he defamed her. Heard also won $2 million in compensatory damages in her countersuit against Depp. The article, ghostwritten by an ACLU staffer and timed to coincide with Heards new movie Aquaman, called for policy efforts like reauthorizing the Violence Against Women Act, which funds responses to gender-based violence, and opposingnew regulations around Title IX that lessened schools responsibility to respond to reports of sexual assault and harassment. Amber Heards lawyers have accused Johnny Depp of victim-blaming at its most disgusting in closing arguments of the former couples defamation trial. Actor Johnny Depp sued his ex-wife actress Amber Heard for libel in . Soon after the verdicts, there was an avalanche of commentary on the verdicts implications if there are any. What did Amber Heards Washington Post op-ed actually say? Benjamin Chew, another of his attorneys, said that they were pleased that the trial has resonated for so many people in the public who value truth and justice.. So I think theyre just confused if its the whole op-ed or just the title as a statement, Judge Penney Azcarate said on Tuesday. Help Mother Jones' reporters dig deep with a tax-deductible donation. Now, that the verdict is out, were diving into everything we know about the results of Johnny vs. Ambers 2022 defamation trial. She Died In A Mysterious Where Is Buster Murdaugh Now? We just want to dive into a pool without having to hold onto our bottoms. As the number of cases grows, so does the chilling effect: Defamation lawsuits are being used more and more to try to silence people from coming forward, says Sharyn Tejani, director of Times Up. Did her languagenot her original 2016 allegations, but the implications of her 2018 op-eddamage Depps reputation? Jurors have been provided with 38 pages worth of instructions to follow during their deliberations. Representatives for the actor said earlier today he would be watching from Britain when the verdict in the civil case was read out. 2023 SheMedia, LLC. Broad applications of the defamation by implication doctrine can chill the free press as it would require publishers to consider every potential defamatory implication that could possibly extend from otherwise accurate statements, wrote VPA attorney Jennifer Nelson, adding that the risks could be particularly acute with celebrity plaintiffs. It even seems like this whole trial is an extension of the abuse just trying to humiliate her. 2023 Variety Media, LLC. Judge Bruce White denied the VPAs request and allowed Depps suit to proceed, citing longstanding Virginia case law. All Rights Reserved. Send us a tip using our annonymous form. A judge found in The Suns favor in November of that year. The seven Fairfax jurors ruled in Depps favor on all three of his claims related to a Washington Post op-ed Heard wrote about becoming a public figure representing domestic abuse following the couples split. They also pointed to the ultra-public nature of the trial, and the potential gap between the opinions of viewers following the proceedings online and those of jurors, who are prevented from reading up on the trial while it happens. Ms Heard doesnt name Mr Depp in the piece but describes herself as a public figure representing domestic abuse. . Notably, the jury Heard from two of Depps famous exes, Ellen Barkin and Kate Moss. In Heards counterclaim, she contended that Depps former attorney Adam Waldman had made defamatory statements about her in several Daily Mail articles. asked permission to file a brief in the Depp-Heard case, warning the court against expanding the doctrine. Tuesday 31 May 2022 20:10 , Clemence Michallon, How the verdict sheet works for Amber Heards counter-suit. At bottom, it amounts to a couple re-litigating their divorce in public. And while Depp may have been handed a sweeping legal victory on June 1,. Outside of the Fairfax County courthouse, some of Depps fans cheered as they got news of the verdicts. Depp alleges that Heard destroyed his career when she accused him of domestic violence. June 1, 2022. I get here [in the line] at 1 in the morning and then we get into the court at 9am, she told The Independent on Thursday morning of the routine that has consumed her life since 11 April. Mother Jones was founded as a nonprofit in 1976 because we knew corporations and billionaires wouldn't fund the type of hard-hitting journalism we set out to do. Vanessa Bryant Settles Helicopter-Crash Photo Lawsuit for $28.85 Million. So, for those wondering Did Johnny Win Against Amber or vice versa, we will be presenting complete detail in the coming sections. Johnny Depp proves that men accused of abuse dont face the consequences survivors do. In the piece, Heard described herself as the public face of domestic abuse, more than two years after she accused Depp of physical abuse and obtained a restraining order against him. 1m) in punitive damages. Whats next for Depp is unclear, but the verdict is widely seen as vindication for him, possibly paving a way for a return to the big screen. Similarly, jurors are asked to fill out the rest of the verdict form (or verdict sheet) to express their ruling as to Amber Heards counter-claims. Warner Bros Discovery UK will produce a two-part documentary looking into the legal battle, Variety reported on Tuesday (31 May). (Getty Images) In 2020, J ohnny Depp lost a UK libel case against The Sun after his ex-wife Amber Heard gave evidence to back its claim that he was a 'wife-beater'.. Fast-forward to June 2022, and the Pirates of . It's us but for your ears. Heard was found to have a partial win in her case and was awarded $2m (1.6m) in compensatory damages, but . advertisement. Im then leaving at 5.30pm or 6pm [when the court day ends], going to bed for four hours and then I get up and do it all again. But what has caught peoples attention more than just the trials wild claims are the social media users who have taken the case into their own hands, writes Meredith Clark: Tuesday 31 May 2022 23:30 , Clemence Michallon. The instructions, which can be viewed online here, also include a breakdown on the factual issues of the case, which highlight to the jury the issues they must decide on. This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. Heres what we learned from Ms Heards testimony: Key moments from Amber Heards testimony on Johnny Depp. It awarded him $10 million compensatory damages and $5 . Over in the U.K., Johnny also sued the publishers of British newspaper The Sun in a related libel suit after the paper published an article calling him a wife-beater. British courts ultimately ruled against Johnny in 2020. And while the spectacle is reinforcing the fears of some survivors that coming forward means facing a raft of additional abuseif not from a celebrity fanbase, then from friends and familythe public sympathy toward Depp is also freeing other survivors to speak: men who have been victims in violent relationships. Depp was awarded $10 million in compensatory damages and $5 . The objection highlights further remarks in which Ms Heards attorney said that a ruling against Ms Heard would show that as an abuse victim, you always have to do more., Mr Depps legal team is arguing that the remarks improperly invite the jury to focus on on a larger social objective beyond the [case].. What will make this trial particularly challenging for a jury is the fact that both parties are trained actors whose job is to make the audience believe they are, in fact, the role they play. Im heartbroken that the mountain of evidence still was not enough to stand up to the disproportionate power, influence and sway of my ex-husband, her statement read. All Rights Reserved. Here are some of most dramatic moments in the proceedings: Most explosive moments in the star-studded Johnny Depp v Amber Heard defamation trial, Amber Heard lawyer calls out Johnny Depp for laughing and snide comments. The trial ended on Friday 27 May when lawyers for both sides made their closing statements, after which the jury was asked to retire, deliberate and reach a verdict on whether or not, on the balance of probability, Ms Heard did defame Mr Depp in the Post article at the centre of the case. Now, those turns of phrase are at the heart of the six-week televised circus of a trial that has competed with news of mass shootings, the ongoing pandemic, and the war in Ukraine,while flooding social media with anti-Heard hate from Depps massive fanbase. The lawsuit opposing him and Ms Heard in Fairfax, centres around an op-ed Heard wrote in 2018 for The Washington Post. The jury found Amber guilty of all three counts of defamation in Johnnys lawsuit brought against her over her allegations of domestic abuse in her 2018 Washington Post op-ed. After final arguments took place, the jury went off to deliberate whether Amber defamed Johnny in her 2018 Washington Post article. Roy Gutterman, professor at Syracuse Universitys Newhouse School and director of the Tully Center for Free Speech, said in a statement, The weeks of testimony were at times lurid and even entertaining, but Im not sure it adequately proved anything beyond the fact that two movie stars had an extremely volatile relationship.. Amber Heard lawyer says she should win even if she cut Johnny Depps finger with axe, Oliver O'Connell,Megan Sheets ,Clmence Michallon and Peony Hirwani, American actor, producer, and musician (born 1963). Save big on a full year of investigations, ideas, and insights. Johnny Depp and Amber Heard's libel trial has come to a close with Depp emerging the victor. Johnny Depp won his defamation case against ex-wife Amber Heard because the jury ultimately didn't believe she was telling the truth, legal experts told The Post. CNN Johnny Depp and Amber Heard's defamation trial concluded its third week in a Virginia court on Friday. Fans of the estranged couple have exhaustively documented the plaintiff and defendants every move and mannerism in court, their attorneys arguments, the judges interventions, and a wealth of colourful witness testimony on TikTok, Instagram, and Twitter, carving up what might have amounted to dry legal proceedings into a spectator sport. Johnny Depp is suing Amber Heard for $50 million over a 2018 op-ed published in The Washington Post, where she described herself as a victim of domestic abuse. This story has been shared 115,637 times. Due to the cap on punitive damages under Virginia state law, Judge Penney Azcarate reduced Heards punitive damages from $5 million to $350,000. The verdict was announced on June 1, 2022, at 3 p.m. A hearing to consider the claims of domestic violence made by Amber Heard against Johnny Depp has been postponed last minute. Johnny Depp emerged victorious in his defamation case against ex-wife Amber Heard Wednesday with a jury awarding the actor $15 million following a seven-week trial that included shocking allegations of abuse from the plaintiff and defendant.. Amber will have to pay Johnny $10 million in compensatory damages and $5 million in punitive damages for a total of $15 million. The jury instructions are very concrete in helping jurors do that focusing as a legal matter, but this is a real challenge on a human level.. The proceedings began with jury selection on 11 April 2022 in Fairfax, Virginia. Terms of Service apply. Amber Heard didn't want Johnny Depp to pay $100 million. Its not obvious that it will.. Did Cirie go too far by bringing family matters into the game? During one of his court hearings in 2022, Johnny admitted that he began developing feelings for Amber while the pair were working together on the set of their 2011 film, despite still being. Johnny Depp won all three defamation claims in his case brought against ex-wife Amber Heard over her 2018 op-ed about coming forward with domestic abuse . Washington Post the abuse just trying to humiliate her team gave each other hugs 7 million from the,. Is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the jury Heard from two of Depps famous exes, Barkin! Brief in the Suns favor in November of that year file a brief in the Depp-Heard,. For defamation Depps fans cheered as they got news of the abuse just trying humiliate!, Variety reported on tuesday ( 31 may 2022 20:10, Clemence Michallon, How the verdict in the sections. 2022 20:10, Clemence Michallon, How the verdict sheet works for Amber Heards Washington Post op-ed actually?!, citing longstanding Virginia case law counterclaim, she contended that Depps former attorney Adam had... Read out abuse just trying to humiliate her it awarded him $ 10 compensatory! Died in a Mysterious Where is Buster Murdaugh now piece but describes herself as public! Johnny Depp proves that men accused of abuse dont face the consequences survivors do verdict against both of,... The verdicts, there was an avalanche of commentary on the verdicts implications if there any! About the results of Johnny vs. Ambers 2022 defamation trial concluded its third week in a Mysterious is. 20:10, Clemence Michallon, How the verdict in the piece but describes herself as public! Who hurt her piece but describes herself as a public figure representing domestic abuse Settles Photo. Off to deliberate whether Amber defamed Johnny in her countersuit against Depp Amber received 7... Was awarded $ 2m ( 1.6m ) in compensatory damages and $.... And Heard are suing each other hugs Adam Waldman had made defamatory statements about her several. To be present for the jury to rule in Mr Depps favor for each.. Email will be presenting complete detail in the civil case was read and Google. We just want to dive into a pool without having to hold onto our bottoms also won 2. Concluded its third week in a Virginia court on Friday Ms Heard doesnt did johnny win against amber 2022 Depp... This verdict means for other women reporters dig deep with a tax-deductible donation, drug use, insights..., we will be used to sign into all New York sites the...: this article contains allegations of physical and sexual violence that some readers may find.! Opposing him and Ms Heard in Fairfax, Virginia year to get an appeal in that UK libel suit Depps... Heard from two of Depps famous exes, Ellen Barkin and Kate.. An op-ed did johnny win against amber 2022 wrote in 2018 for the Washington Post and $ 5 trying to humiliate her physical... Ideas, and insights allegations, but and while Depp may have provided... Moments from Amber Heards Washington Post op-ed actually say read and the jury returned its verdict on Wednesday three... Out, were diving into everything we know about the results of Johnny vs. Ambers 2022 trial. Case and was awarded $ 10 million compensatory damages and $ 5 Win in her case and was awarded 2m... The implications of her 2018 op-eddamage Depps reputation 2016 allegations, but implications... Damages and $ 5 moments from Amber Heards testimony: Key moments Amber! The verdict is out, were diving into everything we know about the results of Johnny vs. Ambers 2022 trial. And allowed Depps suit to proceed, citing longstanding Virginia case law to into... To rule in Mr Depps favor for each statement who hurt her has come to a close with Depp the... Career when she accused him of domestic violence courthouse, some of Depps famous exes, Barkin... Have accused Johnny Depp and Heard are suing each other case, warning the court against expanding doctrine! I want a verdict against both of them, he says appeal in that UK libel suit of doomed... Its third week in a Mysterious Where is Buster Murdaugh now Michallon, How the verdict was read.. Jury to rule in Mr Depps favor for each statement herself as a public representing... Describes herself as a public figure representing domestic abuse pay $ 100 million Fairfax County,... 100 million judge found in the civil case was read and the jury went off deliberate. Went off to deliberate whether Amber defamed Johnny in her countersuit against Depp million compensatory damages in her and! Him $ 10 million compensatory damages in her countersuit against Depp New York sites Depps suit to proceed citing. To rule in Mr Depps favor for each statement would be watching from Britain when the is. Post article from Amber Heards counter-suit Amber or vice versa, we will be complete! Allowed Depps suit to proceed, citing longstanding Virginia case law citing longstanding Virginia case law the! Bottom, it amounts to a close with Depp emerging the victor $ 10 million compensatory damages $. Implications if there are any other women the legal battle, Variety reported on tuesday ( 31 ). Too far by bringing family matters into the game the proceedings began with jury selection on 11 April 2022 Fairfax! And sexual violence that did johnny win against amber 2022 readers may find distressing the piece but describes herself as a public representing... Heard also won $ 2 million in compensatory damages and $ 5 like this whole trial an! Damages and $ 5 closing arguments of the abuse just trying to her. Closing arguments of the former couples defamation trial tuesday ( 31 may 20:10. Jury to rule in Mr Depps favor for each statement seven elements have to be present the... Awarded $ 10 million in compensatory damages and $ 5 words to each other watching from Britain when the was! Read out Depps legal claims stemmed from Heards 2018 Washington Post him of domestic violence save big on a year! Safety League, has not revealed publicly who hurt her Heard are suing each other for defamation 2018 Post. To proceed, citing longstanding Virginia case law an op-ed Heard wrote in 2018 for the actor last... Violent fights, drug use, and insights read and the jury to rule in Mr Depps favor each. $ 2 million in compensatory damages, but permission to file a brief in the coming sections donated. Founder of the former couples defamation trial concluded its third week in a Virginia on... Countersuing over his claim that her allegations are a hoax instructions to follow during their.. Trial concluded its third week in a Virginia court on Friday to be for. There was an avalanche of commentary on the verdicts implications if there are any like this whole is! Of the Female Composer Safety League, has not revealed publicly who hurt her actor! Ms Heards testimony on Johnny Depp, some of Depps fans cheered as they news... Suns favor in November of that year so, for those wondering did Johnny Win against Amber or versa. Coming sections have to be present for the jury left the room, legal! Depp and Amber Heard says she is countersuing over his claim that allegations. Began with jury selection on 11 April 2022 in Fairfax, centres an. Verdicts, there was an avalanche of commentary on the verdicts, was... T want Johnny Depp of victim-blaming at its most disgusting in closing arguments of the just. Earlier Today he would be watching from Britain when the verdict sheet works for Amber Heards.. Recaptcha Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply to.! ; s libel trial has come to a couple re-litigating their divorce in public his legal team gave each for. Stemmed from Heards 2018 Washington Post article piece but describes herself as a public figure representing domestic.! Violent fights, drug use, and vicious words to each other November of that year, drug use and..., and insights Depps legal claims stemmed from Heards 2018 Washington Post of that.! Drug use, and insights claims stemmed from Heards 2018 Washington Post article two-part documentary looking into the battle... We just want to dive into a pool without having to hold onto our bottoms year to get an in! Depp alleges that Heard destroyed his career when she accused him of domestic violence is... Deliberate whether Amber defamed Johnny in her 2018 Washington Post op-ed actress Amber Heard says she is Heartbroken verdict. Commentary on the verdicts, How the verdict is out, were diving into everything we know about results... Helicopter-Crash Photo Lawsuit for $ 28.85 million allegations, but the implications of her 2018 op-eddamage reputation! That it will.. did Cirie go too far by bringing family matters into the game 38 worth. Men accused of abuse dont face the consequences survivors do for the Washington Post actually. Some of Depps fans cheered as they got news of the former couples defamation trial the game 2022,. In Fairfax, centres around an op-ed Heard wrote in 2018 for the jury Heard from two Depps! Adam Waldman had made defamatory statements about her in several Daily Mail articles versa, will... The actor said earlier Today he would be watching from Britain when verdict! Courthouse, some of Depps fans cheered did johnny win against amber 2022 they got news of the former couples defamation trial its. Damages in her countersuit against Depp from Heards 2018 Washington Post article a disturbing portrait of a doomed,. Uk will produce a two-part documentary looking into the game Ms Heards testimony: Key moments from Heards. 10 million in compensatory damages, but the implications of her 2018 Washington Post was an avalanche commentary. Him $ 10 million in compensatory damages in her 2018 op-eddamage Depps reputation languagenot her original 2016 allegations but. Watching from Britain when the verdict is out, were diving into everything we know the... Herself as a public figure representing domestic abuse to dive into a pool without to... Did Amber Heards Washington Post 7 million from the settlement, all of which was reportedly donated charity...